McMaster U
Exhibitions
  • Current
  • Upcoming
  • Past
  • Publications
  • Submissions + Assistance
Collections
  • eMuseum
  • Recent Acquisitions
  • Public Art Commissions
  • Coin Collection
Education
  • Group Tours + Classes
  • Education Programs
  • The Art of Seeing Program
  • Research Appointments
About
  • Mission + Vision
  • Staff Directory
  • News
Visit
  • Directions + Hours
  • Tours
  • Events
  • Library
  • Room Bookings
Support
  • Membership
  • Volunteer
  • Donate
  • Supporters

Frames: Encompassing an Artwork

July 25, 2012

Woman in landscape in painting in ornate gold frame

Art and our interaction with it always operates within a context. When you visit an art museum, an often overlooked part of that context is the artwork’s frame.

In her excellent book on the topic, Deborah Davis writes:

Whether oversized and gilded or small and dark, intricately carved or smooth and polished, the frame is always at the mercy of shifting tastes and trends that could cause it to be removed, replaced, condemned to storage, or, worst of all, destroyed.

(The Secret Lives of Frames: One Hundred Years of Art And Artistry, by Deborah Davis, Filipacchi Publishing, 2006, pg 9)

Frames and their shifting styles and importance is a young field of study. In the past, frames were often altered or discarded with a change of ownership. (Check out this page on frames from the Met Museum)

Three paintings currently on display in the MMA’s 125 & 45 exhibit are wonderful examples of this storied saga of the artwork frame.

The first of these paintings I’d like to discuss is Otto Dix’s Anna Grunebaum. While the majority of the frames in the collection do not have a precise history, tied to the original artwork itself, Dix’s frame for Anna is most certainly documented as the original. In fact, Dix designed the frame himself. He created it to particularly evoke visual associations with German Renaissance panel paintings; the simplified floral motif Dix employed is a variant of a pattern use as early as the late 14th century. Dix was very interested in the historic art of Germany; his interest in this field extended to late medieval methods of paint and panel preparation. Looking at Anna Grunebaum is a fantastic juxtaposition of Dix’s modern style and an historic method.

Detail of frame on Otto Dix painting

The second painting with an interesting frame (or, lack thereof!) is David Burliuk’s Landscape with Watering Can. Completed in the 1940s, this painting was initially displayed in museum with a period-appropriate frame. It hangs unframed in the current 125 & 45 exhibit.

This raises interesting questions about what a frame does for an artwork. Or perhaps, what a frame does to an artwork. Burliuk’s colourful, impasto painting was encased in a simple, wood, white frame with a sheet of glass covering the work. While this method of framing provided a conservation-friendly microclimate and protection from both fingertips and dust, it also created a barrier between the viewer and the art, making it difficult to see Burliuk’s thick paint application. I’m glad to say many visitors appear to greatly appreciate this change in frame.

Woman in landscape in painting in ornate gold frame

The last painting is one with a frame which has provoked very different reactions from visitors; George Agnew Reid’s A Call To Dinner. You may recall Reid’s painting from the recent post. In that post, the painting was shown with the frame cropped out. Above, you see it with its bold, large and bright frame included. Visitors have shared their various reactions to this frame/painting combination with me, and I’ve been very interested to hear that it’s regarded as either distracting or supportive, inappropriate or complimentary. Its history may be linked to Gabriel Max’s 1878 painting The Raising of Jarius’ Daughter, in the collection of (and now on view at) the Montreal Museum of Fine Art. According to Muriel Miller Miner (George Reid’s biographer, 1946), Reid painted A Call to Dinner specifically to fit the frame that had been originally intended for the Max painting. Max’s painting received a different custom frame.

Come and see these three works now until August 4. I’d love to hear what you think of the frame and artwork together!

– Teresa Gregorio, Museum Monitor / Information Officer, McMaster Museum of Art

VIEW ARCHIVE
Link to News Archive for a complete list of past news articles

McMaster Museum of Art Launches Two Cross-Campus Exhibitions this April, in Collaboration with McMaster University Library and School of the Arts
March 28, 2025

Read More

McMaster Museum of Art Hiring Communications Officer (16-month contract)
March 21, 2025

Read More

McMaster Museum of Art Welcomes Mary Reid as Director and Chief Curator
February 4, 2025

Read More

Contact

Tel.:  905-525-9140
Ext.:  23081 for main menu
Ext.:  23241 for reception desk
Email:  museum@mcmaster.ca
Map and Directions

Admission

Pay what you can, if you can, with a suggested donation of $2.00

If there is an AODA web accessibility issue with this website, please email museum@mcmaster.ca

All galleries are wheelchair accessible. Read more about accessibility at McMaster.

Hours

Tuesday 11am-5pm
Wednesday 11am-5pm
Thursday 11am-7pm
Friday 11am-5pm
Saturday - Monday Closed

Closed statutory holidays and from December 24 - January 6, 2025

Sign up for our invitations

Enter your e-mail below

black MMA logo
  • black instagram logo
  • black twitter logo
  • black facebook logo
  • black youtube logo

McMaster University recognizes and acknowledges that it is located on the traditional territories of the Mississauga and Haudenosaunee nations, and within the lands protected by the Dish With One Spoon wampum agreement.

© 2021 McMaster Museum of Art | Alvin A. Lee Bldg, University Ave | McMaster University | 1280 Main St W | Hamilton, Ontario L8S 4L6 | 905-525-9140 | Contact | Terms of Use & Privacy Policy

  • black instagram logo
  • black twitter logo
  • black facebook logo
  • black youtube logo
black MMA logo
black mcmaster university logo